Rethinking Dietary Fats: What New Research Reveals About Plant vs. Animal Fats

For decades, dietary advice focused mainly on whether fats were saturated or unsaturated. However, large, high-quality studies from 2024–2025 now show that the source of fat—plant or animal—matters just as much, if not more. In a landmark analysis of over 400,000 adults followed for 24 years, higher intake of plant-based fats was associated with significantly lower overall and cardiovascular mortality, while animal fats, especially from red and processed meat, were linked to higher risk (Zhao et al., 2024). Importantly, replacing just 5% of daily calories from animal fats with plant fats—roughly two tablespoons of olive oil—reduced the risk of death and heart disease.

Beyond heart health, plant-based fats also appear to reduce visceral (belly) fat, a key driver of insulin resistance and type 2 diabetes, even when weight loss is modest (Vij et al., 2025). Not all fats traditionally labeled “healthy” act the same: plant-derived monounsaturated fats lower diabetes risk, while those from animal sources show neutral or adverse associations (Chen et al., 2025). At the same time, emerging evidence suggests that total fat quantity still matters, reinforcing moderation—even with healthy oils (David et al., 2025).

In simple terms, choosing olive oil, nuts, seeds, and avocados as primary fat sources—while limiting fats from red and processed meats—offers measurable, long-term benefits for heart health, metabolism, and longevity.

Clinical Pearks

1. The "Source Over Saturation" Rule

For a long time, we focused only on saturated versus unsaturated fats. However, recent 2024–2025 research shows that the source of the fat—plant versus animal—is a stronger predictor of longevity. Even if the fat type is similar, plant-based fats (like those in olive oil and nuts) consistently show a protective effect on the heart, whereas fats from red and processed meats are linked to higher cardiovascular risk.

2. The 5% "Micro-Swap" Benefit

You don’t need a total dietary overhaul to see results. Studies show that replacing just 5% of your daily calories from animal fats (like butter or lard) with plant-based fats (like avocado or olive oil) can reduce overall mortality risk by about 4%. Scientifically, this is an isocaloric substitution—keeping calories the same but improving the "quality" of the fuel—which significantly lowers systemic inflammation.

3. Targeting the "Metabolic Fire" (Visceral Fat)

Not all body fat is created equal. Visceral fat—the deep fat that wraps around your organs—is a primary driver of insulin resistance and "metabolic fire" (inflammation). Research indicates that predominantly plant-based fats specifically help reduce this dangerous visceral fat more effectively than conventional diets, even if your total body weight stays relatively stable.

4. The "Package Deal" Concept

In science, we look at the nutritional matrix. When you eat plant fats, they come "bundled" with fiber, antioxidants, and phytochemicals that help your body process the fat healthily. Animal fats often come bundled with heme iron and cholesterol, which can promote oxidative stress. By choosing plant fats, you aren't just getting "healthy fat"; you're getting a protective delivery system that helps stabilize your blood sugar.

5. Monounsaturated Fats: Context Matters

Monounsaturated fats (MUFAs) are often called "heart-healthy," but context is key. MUFAs from plant sources (olive oil, avocados) are associated with a significantly lower risk of Type 2 diabetes. However, MUFAs from animal sources (dairy or meat) do not show the same protective benefit. This highlights that the heart-healthy label for MUFAs depends entirely on whether they come from a tree or a farm.

Why This Research Matters Now

Before we get into the studies, let's acknowledge the elephant in the room: Americans consume roughly 35% of their daily calories from fat. With heart disease remaining the leading cause of death in the United States and type 2 diabetes affecting over 37 million Americans, understanding which fats protect us and which harm us has never been more critical.

The research we're examining today represents some of the most comprehensive investigations into fat intake ever conducted, following hundreds of thousands of people for decades and using cutting-edge analysis techniques.

Study 1: The Game-Changer—Plant Fats Save Lives, Animal Fats Don't

Zhao and colleagues published what might be the most important fat research of the decade in JAMA Internal Medicine. This massive study followed 407,531 participants from the NIH-AARP Diet and Health Study for an average of 24 years, documenting 185,111 deaths, including 58,526 from cardiovascular disease (Zhao et al., 2024).

The results were striking. People who consumed the most plant-based fats had a 9% lower risk of overall death and a 12% lower risk of cardiovascular death compared to those eating the least (Zhao et al., 2024). Meanwhile, those consuming the most animal fats faced a 16% higher risk of overall death and a 14% higher cardiovascular mortality risk.

But here's where it gets really interesting: when participants replaced just 5% of their calories from animal fats with equivalent plant fats, their overall mortality risk dropped by 4%, and their CVD mortality risk fell by 5% (Zhao et al., 2024). That's the equivalent of swapping about two tablespoons of butter for olive oil daily.

The researchers found that dairy fats and egg fats showed neutral associations with mortality, while meat fats—particularly from processed meat and red meat—were the primary culprits driving increased death rates.

This isn't about going completely plant-based overnight. Small, strategic swaps can make a meaningful difference. Replace meat-based fats with nuts, seeds, avocados, or olive oil where possible, and you're already moving in the right direction.

Study 2: The Hidden Belly Fat Connection

While we've long known that diet affects weight, a 2025 systematic review and meta-analysis by Vij and colleagues specifically examined how plant-based diets impact visceral fat—the dangerous fat that wraps around your organs and drives metabolic disease.

Analyzing data from multiple studies, researchers found that predominantly plant-based diets significantly reduced visceral adipose tissue compared to conventional diets (Vij et al., 2025). This matters because visceral fat is strongly linked to insulin resistance, type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and even certain cancers.

The reduction wasn't just statistically significant—it was clinically meaningful. Participants following plant-based eating patterns showed measurable decreases in the most metabolically harmful fat deposits, even when overall weight loss was modest.

You can be a healthy weight on the outside but still carry dangerous visceral fat on the inside. Plant-based fats appear to specifically target this problematic fat depot, offering metabolic benefits beyond what the scale might show.

Study 3: Not All Monounsaturated Fats Are Created Equal

We've been told for years that monounsaturated fatty acids (MUFAs) are heart-healthy. But Chen and colleagues asked a more nuanced question: do MUFAs from plants and animals affect diabetes risk differently?

Their study followed three large prospective cohorts—the Nurses' Health Study, Nurses' Health Study II, and Health Professionals Follow-up Study—totaling over 200,000 participants for up to 36 years, documenting 20,777 cases of type 2 diabetes (Chen et al., 2025).

The results challenged conventional wisdom. While total MUFA intake showed a modest association with diabetes risk, the source made all the difference. Plant-derived MUFAs—from foods like olive oil, avocados, and nuts—were associated with reduced diabetes risk (Chen et al., 2025). In contrast, animal-derived MUFAs—from red meat and dairy—showed neutral or even slightly elevated risk associations.

When participants replaced 5% of energy from animal MUFAs with plant MUFAs, their type 2 diabetes risk decreased significantly. The researchers suggested this might be due to the broader nutritional package: plant fats come bundled with fiber, phytochemicals, and antioxidants, while animal fats often accompany saturated fat, cholesterol, and heme iron (Chen et al., 2025).

Don't just focus on getting more monounsaturated fats—focus on getting them from the right sources. That olive oil on your salad is doing something fundamentally different in your body than the fat from a ribeye steak, even if they're both high in MUFAs.

Study 4: Quantity Matters More Than We Thought

In a fascinating animal study that has important implications for humans, David and colleagues investigated whether the amount of fat consumed matters more than its saturation level for cardiac health. Published in Scientific Reports, this research used rat models to carefully control fat quantity and quality (David et al., 2025).

The researchers found that high-fat diets—regardless of saturation level—predisposed cardiac tissues to greater metabolic risk compared to the type of saturation (David et al., 2025). Animals consuming larger quantities of fat showed more pronounced metabolic dysfunction, inflammatory markers, and cardiac tissue changes than those consuming moderate amounts, even when the fat was less saturated.

This suggests that while fat quality (plant vs. animal, saturated vs. unsaturated) matters tremendously, fat quantity also plays an independent role in cardiovascular risk. The study challenges the notion that you can eat unlimited amounts of "healthy" fats without consequence.

Even healthy fats from plants need to be consumed in reasonable amounts. While olive oil and avocados are nutritious, they're also calorie-dense. The Mediterranean diet—often cited as the gold standard—emphasizes plant fats but uses them judiciously, not excessively.

Study 5: The American College of Cardiology Weighs In

In a comprehensive journal scan published by the American College of Cardiology, Zhao and colleagues reviewed the evidence on plant and animal fat intake and its relationship to overall mortality and CVD mortality, synthesizing findings from the major JAMA Internal Medicine study discussed earlier (Zhao et al., 2024).

The ACC analysis highlighted several critical points for clinicians and patients. First, the dose-response relationship was clear: each 5% increase in plant fat intake was associated with progressively lower mortality risk, while each 5% increase in animal fat showed the opposite pattern.

Second, the protective effects of plant fats appeared to work through multiple mechanisms: improving lipid profiles, reducing inflammation, enhancing endothelial function, and supporting healthy gut microbiome composition (Zhao et al., 2024).

Third, the findings held true across diverse populations, different baseline health statuses, and various levels of physical activity—suggesting these are robust, widely applicable findings rather than quirks of a specific population.

Major medical organizations are increasingly incorporating this research into clinical guidelines. Your doctor's nutritional advice is likely shifting to emphasize plant-based fat sources as a cornerstone of cardiovascular disease prevention.

The Big Picture: What All This Research Tells Us

• 1. Source Matters More Than Type

  The old paradigm focused almost exclusively on saturated versus unsaturated fats. The new science shows that whether your fat comes from plants or animals may be even more important. Plant-based fats—whether from olive oil, nuts, seeds, or avocados—consistently show protective effects against mortality, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and visceral fat accumulation.

• 2. Not All Animal Fats Are Equally Harmful

  While animal fats as a category show concerning associations with health outcomes, there's nuance here. Dairy fats and egg fats appear relatively neutral, while red meat fats and especially processed meat fats drive most of the negative associations (Zhao et al., 2024). This suggests that modest amounts of dairy and eggs might fit into a healthy diet, while heavily processed and red meats deserve more caution.

• 3. Small Changes Add Up

  The research consistently shows that replacing just 5% of calories from animal fats with plant fats produces measurable benefits. For most people, that's achievable without a complete dietary overhaul—we're talking about swapping your cooking fat, choosing nuts instead of cheese for a snack, or adding avocado to your sandwich instead of bacon.

• 4. Quality AND Quantity Both Matter

  While choosing plant-based fats is crucial, eating unlimited amounts isn't a free pass. The research reminds us that total fat intake matters independently of source (David et al., 2025). The sweet spot appears to be moderate amounts of high-quality plant fats, not unlimited quantities

  .

• 5. The Benefits Extend Beyond Cardiovascular Health

  These studies show that choosing plant fats over animal fats affects not just your heart, but also your diabetes risk (Chen et al., 2025), visceral fat accumulation (Vij et al., 2025), overall mortality, and likely numerous other health outcomes not measured in these particular studies.

Practical Implementation: Your Action Plan

• In Your Kitchen:

  Replace butter with extra virgin olive oil for cooking and as a bread spread. Stock your pantry with avocado oil for high-heat cooking. Keep a variety of raw nuts and seeds easily accessible for snacking. Choose nut butters (almond, peanut, cashew) instead of cream cheese or butter on your morning toast.

• At the Grocery Store:

  Read labels carefully—many processed foods contain palm oil or coconut oil, which are plant-based but highly saturated. Choose products made with olive oil, canola oil, or other unsaturated plant oils. Select fatty fish like salmon, mackerel, and sardines when you do eat animal products, as these provide beneficial omega-3 fatty acids.

• At Restaurants:

  Ask for salads dressed with olive oil and vinegar rather than cream-based dressings. Choose dishes featuring nuts, avocados, or olive oil as primary fat sources. When you do eat meat, choose leaner cuts and smaller portions, treating it as a side dish rather than the meal's centerpiece.

• Mindset Shifts:

  Stop thinking of fat as simply "good" or "bad"—think about where it comes from. Recognize that even healthy changes take time to show results; the studies followed people for decades. Don't aim for perfection—consistent, moderate improvements matter more than occasional perfect days followed by reverting to old patterns.

Common Questions and Concerns Addressed

"Isn't saturated fat from coconut oil different because it's plant-based?"

This is a great question that these studies highlight. While coconut oil is technically plant-based, it's approximately 90% saturated fat—higher than butter. The research suggests that the benefits of plant fats come primarily from unsaturated varieties like those in olive oil, nuts, and avocados. Coconut oil likely sits somewhere between typical plant oils and animal fats in terms of health effects—not the superfood it's sometimes marketed as, but probably not as harmful as butter either. Moderation is key.

"I've heard the Mediterranean diet is healthy, but it includes fish and some dairy. How does that fit?"

The Mediterranean diet is actually a perfect real-world example of these principles in action. It emphasizes olive oil as the primary fat source, includes abundant nuts and seeds, features fish rather than red meat as the main animal protein, and includes modest amounts of cheese and yogurt. This pattern aligns beautifully with the research: prioritize plant fats, choose fish over meat, and keep dairy moderate. The key is that plant fats dominate, with animal fats playing a supporting role.

"Can I really make a difference if I just make small changes?"

Absolutely. The research specifically quantified this: replacing just 5% of calories from animal fat with plant fat reduced overall mortality risk by 4% and CVD mortality by 5% (Zhao et al., 2024). For a person consuming 2,000 calories daily, 5% is just 100 calories—roughly two tablespoons of olive oil instead of butter, or a handful of almonds instead of cheese. Small, consistent changes compound over time.

"I'm worried about the cost of olive oil and nuts. Are there affordable plant fat options?"

Cost is a legitimate concern. Fortunately, several affordable plant fat sources exist: peanut butter is typically cheaper than other nut butters and still provides plant-based fats; canola oil offers a good fatty acid profile at a lower price point than olive oil (save the expensive extra virgin olive oil for dishes where you'll taste it, like salads); sunflower seeds are usually more affordable than almonds or walnuts; store-brand versions of these items often cost significantly less than name brands without compromising quality.

"What about people with nut allergies?"

Plant-based fats extend far beyond nuts. Focus on seeds (sunflower, pumpkin, chia, flax), avocados, olives, olive oil, avocado oil, and canola oil. Soy-based foods like edamame and tofu also provide some plant fats along with protein. The variety of plant fat sources means almost everyone can find options that work for their dietary restrictions.

Limitations and What We Still Don't Know

Good science requires acknowledging limitations. While these studies are robust and well-designed, they're primarily observational, meaning they show associations but can't definitively prove causation (though the consistency across multiple large studies strengthens the case considerably).

Most participants in these studies were from Western countries, predominantly the United States and Finland. While the findings likely apply broadly, we need more research in diverse populations with different baseline diets and genetic backgrounds.

The studies also couldn't fully account for every confounding variable. People who choose plant-based fats might also engage in other healthy behaviors that contribute to better outcomes. The researchers controlled for many factors, but residual confounding remains possible.

We still need more research on specific plant fat sources—are walnuts better than almonds? Is avocado oil superior to olive oil? The current evidence suggests all plant-based unsaturated fats are beneficial, but we're still learning about the nuances.

Finally, while animal studies like those examining cardiac tissue responses provide valuable mechanistic insights (David et al., 2025), findings don't always translate perfectly to humans. However, when animal research aligns with human observational studies, as it does here, our confidence in the conclusions increases.

The Bottom Line: Science-Backed Recommendations

• Prioritize plant-based fats from sources like olive oil, avocados, nuts, and seeds as your primary dietary fats. These consistently show protective effects against mortality, cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, and visceral fat accumulation.

• Reduce animal fats, especially from red meat and processed meats. If you consume animal products, choose fatty fish, and keep dairy and eggs moderate—these show neutral rather than harmful associations.

• Make strategic substitutions: Replace animal-based fats with plant-based alternatives in cooking, snacking, and meal planning. Even small changes (5% of calories) produce measurable benefits.

• Mind quantity as well as quality: Even healthy plant fats should be consumed in moderation as part of a balanced diet. They're calorie-dense, and total fat intake still matters for health outcomes.

• Focus on whole food sources: Get your plant fats from minimally processed sources when possible—whole nuts instead of nut butters, olives alongside olive oil, avocados in addition to avocado oil.

Your Next Steps

This Week:

• Replace your current cooking oil with extra virgin olive oil or avocado oil

• Buy a variety of raw, unsalted nuts to keep on hand for snacking

• Try adding avocado to one meal where you'd typically use cheese or butter

This Month:

• Experiment with one new plant-based fat source weekly (maybe tahini, hemp seeds, or flaxseed oil)

• Gradually reduce your red meat consumption, replacing it with fish, legumes, or plant-based proteins

• Learn one new recipe featuring olive oil or nuts as a star ingredient

This Year:

• Make plant-based fats your default choice in cooking and snacking

• Reserve animal fats for occasional treats rather than daily staples

• Share what you've learned with friends and family—dietary changes stick better with social support

Key Takeaways

✓ Plant-based fats reduce overall mortality by 9% and cardiovascular mortality by 12% compared to diets high in animal fats (Zhao et al., 2024)

✓ Replacing just 5% of calories from animal fats with plant fats significantly reduces death risk—that's roughly two tablespoons of olive oil instead of butter daily (Zhao et al., 2024)

✓ Plant-based diets specifically reduce dangerous visceral fat that wraps around organs and drives metabolic disease (Vij et al., 2025)

✓ Monounsaturated fats from plants (like olive oil) reduce diabetes risk, while those from animals show neutral or slightly elevated risk (Chen et al., 2025)

✓ Both the quantity and quality of fat intake matter for cardiac health—even healthy fats should be consumed in moderation (David et al., 2025)

✓ Red meat and processed meat fats drive most negative health associations, while dairy and egg fats appear relatively neutral

✓ The source of your fat matters as much or more than whether it's saturated or unsaturated

✓ Small, consistent dietary changes compound into significant health benefits over time

✓ Major medical organizations like the American College of Cardiology are incorporating this evidence into clinical guidelines

✓ You don't need dietary perfection—strategic substitutions of plant fats for animal fats make a measurable difference

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Do I need to become vegan to get these health benefits?

A: No. The research shows benefits from replacing animal fats with plant fats, not necessarily eliminating animal products entirely. The Mediterranean diet, which includes fish and modest dairy, demonstrates that a plant-fat-forward approach works even with some animal products. The key is making plant-based fats your primary fat source.

Q: What about keto or other high-fat diets?

A: The research suggests that total fat quantity matters independently of quality (David et al., 2025). While you can do a higher-fat diet with primarily plant sources, extremely high-fat intake (typical of ketogenic diets) may carry risks regardless of source. If following a higher-fat eating pattern, prioritize plant-based sources and monitor your health markers with your healthcare provider.

Q: Are there any situations where animal fats are better?

A: The research doesn't identify scenarios where animal fats are superior to plant fats for health outcomes. However, fatty fish like salmon provide beneficial omega-3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA) that are harder to obtain from plant sources, making them a valuable animal food to include regularly.

Q: How quickly will I see benefits from switching to plant fats?

A: Some benefits, like improved cholesterol levels, can occur within weeks to months. Others, like reduced cardiovascular disease risk, represent long-term probability shifts that become apparent over years or decades. The important thing is that positive changes begin immediately at the cellular level, even before you see measurable results.

Q: Can children and pregnant women follow these recommendations?

A: Yes, plant-based fats are appropriate and beneficial for all life stages, including childhood and pregnancy. In fact, establishing healthy fat preferences early may set children up for better health throughout life. However, pregnant and breastfeeding women should ensure adequate intake of omega-3 fatty acids, potentially through fatty fish or algae-based supplements, as these are crucial for fetal brain development.

Q: What if I don't like the taste of olive oil or nuts?

A: Plant-based fats come in many forms with varied flavors. Try different varieties: avocado oil has a milder taste than olive oil; cashews are sweeter and creamier than almonds; sunflower seed butter tastes different from peanut butter. You can also incorporate plant fats in ways where you won't directly taste them, like using olive oil in baked goods or blending avocado into smoothies.

Q: Do I need to buy expensive, premium plant fats?

A: Not necessarily. While extra virgin olive oil has additional antioxidants worth paying for when using it raw (on salads or bread), regular olive oil or canola oil works fine for cooking. Store-brand nuts have the same nutritional profile as premium brands. Focus on affordability and accessibility—consistent use of affordable plant fats beats occasional use of premium versions.

Conclusion: The Source-Centric Paradigm Shift

The scientific consensus of 2024–2025 marks a definitive transition from a nutrient-centric to a source-centric model of lipidology. Large-scale prospective data, including the landmark NIH-AARP study, confirm that the biological impact of dietary fat is dictated more by its food matrix than its degree of saturation alone. While animal-derived fats—particularly those from red and processed meats—are consistently associated with increased systemic inflammation and cardiovascular mortality, plant-derived fats act as potent metabolic modulators.

Mechanistically, the "bundling" of plant fats with fiber, polyphenols, and antioxidants facilitates a superior isocaloric substitution effect. This not only optimizes lipid profiles but actively targets visceral adipose tissue and restores insulin sensitivity through enhanced GLUT4 translocation. Furthermore, the finding that plant-derived monounsaturated fats (MUFAs) provide specific protection against Type 2 diabetes—whereas animal-derived MUFAs remain neutral—underscores the importance of the phytochemical package. Ultimately, clinical practice must pivot toward encouraging the replacement of animal fats with plant-based alternatives. This strategic shift represents a high-yield, evidence-based intervention for reducing chronic disease burden and extending the human healthspan.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Individual circumstances vary, and treatment decisions should always be made in consultation with qualified healthcare professionals.

Related Articles

How Polyphenols Improve Insulin Sensitivity: The Gut-Metabolite Connection That's Revolutionizing Metabolic Health | DR T S DIDWAL

Feed Your Gut, Fuel Your Health: Diet, Microbiota, and Systemic Health | DR T S DIDWAL

What’s New in the 2025 Blood Pressure Guidelines? A Complete Scientific Breakdown | DR T S DIDWAL

Low-Fat vs. Low-Carb: Which Diet is Best for Weight Loss? | DR T S DIDWAL

5 Steps to Reverse Metabolic Syndrome: Diet, Habit, & Lifestyle Plan | DR T S DIDWAL

The Role of Cholesterol in Health and Disease: Beyond the "Bad" Label | DR T S DIDWAL

Lowering Cholesterol with Food: 4 Phases of Dietary Dyslipidemia Treatment | DR T S DIDWAL

High Triglyceride Levels: 5 New Facts to Help You Lower Your Risk | DR T S DIDWAL

The Best Dietary Fat Balance for Insulin Sensitivity, Inflammation, and Longevity | DR T S DIDWAL

References

Chen, Z., Qian, F., Liu, B., Zong, G., Li, Y., Hu, F. B., & Sun, Q. (2025). Monounsaturated fatty acids from plant or animal sources and risk of type 2 diabetes in three large prospective cohorts of men and women. Diabetologia, 68(4), 801–814. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00125-024-06353-8

David, U. E., Aluko, E. O., Ojetola, A. A., Owolabi, O. V., Ogunlade, B., Adeyemi, W. J., Umoren, E. B., & Akhigbe, R. E. (2025). Quantity of fat consumed predisposes cardiac tissues to greater metabolic risk than their level of saturation. Scientific Reports, 15, Article 34430. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-17493-1

Vij, V. A., Deshmukh, K., Vijayageetha, M., Goyal, C., Gumashta, J., & Gandhi, A. P. (2025). Effect of predominantly plant-based diets on visceral fat: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics, 38(2), Article e70055. https://doi.org/10.1111/jhn.70055

Zhao, B., Gan, L., Graubard, B. I., Männistö, S., Albanes, D., & Weinstein, S. J. (2024, August 19). Plant and animal fat intake and overall and CVD mortality. American College of Cardiology. https://www.acc.org/latest-in-cardiology/journal-scans/2024/08/19/16/43/plant-and-animal-fat

Zhao, B., Männistö, S., Fang, F., Sinha, R., Liao, L., Gan, L., Huang, J., Weinstein, S., Graubard, B., Chen, X., & Albanes, D. (2024). Plant and animal fat intake and overall and cardiovascular disease mortality. JAMA Internal Medicine, 184(10), 1234–1245. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamainternmed.2024.3799